Skip to content
Urban Vibes

Guardians That Record Their Young Ones Weeping for Views Should Examine at Themselves

A particular song has been residing in my head this seven days, and no, it doesn't come from Taylor Swift's recent album. It comes by a much more accomplished songwriter: a children's entertainer. The track is titled Big Feelings and its lyrics declare: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”

The Emergence of Big Feelings Online

Thanks to the trend for conscious parenting, the notion of “big feelings” has transformed into lucrative online, and generally I appreciate that. Being a parent, powerful emotions are difficult to ignore: you're having them, the little one in your household is experiencing them and, in one of the most significant departures for us as a humanity, so are myriad other children on your social media feed.

Truly, recordings of babies and children crying is so commonplace on certain platforms that a lot of parents see it as normal. I do not use TikTok and my Instagram feed is primarily fixated on soup and magic, but when a friend mentioned that she thought the trend concerning, not to mention unethical, I watched some of the clips myself.

What I Found: Kids at Their Most Fragile

What I discovered was recording after recording of children at their most fragile. Sobbing, yelling, screaming, and sometimes acting out. I have certainly been observant to these moments in my own house, but seeing another person's child going through it feels profoundly disturbing, notably when that child is not receiving solace by their own parent. Hardest to excuse is a category of video in which parents put their children to medical procedures while their baby or toddler cries and screams directly to camera. It is important to mention that the majority of the videos are not as extreme, and yet there is nonetheless something unsettling about them all.

When Big Feelings Aren't Upsetting

Of course, “big feelings” are not always completely traumatic. When your child is lying on the ground heartbroken at the discovery that cake isn't infinite it can be challenging to avoid laughing. Numerous of us have been entertained by tales of particularly unforgettable tantrums of our own. My own featured screaming “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the lobby of the a modern art venue in downtown. Lightheartedly joking your child about a time they had a meltdown, or laughing about it with your spouse once they have retired for the night, is one thing. Filming a child in a time of distress and posting it to the online world for all to see lacking approval is a distinct concern altogether.

Unpleasant Trends and Embarrassment

Then you have the phenomena that are plainly disturbing, such as a trend that included startling babies out of crying by tossing a processed food at their faces, or breaking an egg on them. Such content seems designed for humiliating children. In a piece for the New York Times, a writer commented: “The most unsettling part of these videos [is that] the parents are barely connecting to their kids. Instead they are relating to a mirror image of their children that they are sharing online. And they are enjoying their authority over that image.”

The Explanation of Teachability

Some video producers who would despise such content. They claim that they are capturing their children at their most vulnerable not for entertainment, but because they are attempting to create learning opportunities – “see how calmly and beautifully I was able to defuse this child’s meltdown using these techniques”. A few even aim to prevent inevitable criticism. “This video is shared to teach and promote knowledge – not for support or opinions”, one video, posted by an account operated by a child doctor, reportedly says. The statement that ensues is one of the most self-applauding foolishness I have read on the online. “If you aren't living the life, refrain from criticizing the moment.”

A Challenge of Obligation

How about you refrain from sharing the moment? I can't help but ask. Because I absolutely question these people. The impression I get, when I observe a video of a youngster in anguish, whether their parent is demonstrating reassurance or not, is a neglect of obligation – the obligation to be present for your child. And I wonder what implication it communicates, when when your child demonstrates a “big feeling”, you start recording. What does that say to your baby about their completely normal emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, reportedly.

Considerations on Modern Upbringing

When my spouse and I begin exploring schools for our son, it’s difficult not to reflect on how strategies to parenting have evolved since we were children. There is an greater understanding of the fact that “big feelings” are par for the course for small children. Nowadays a lot of adults aim to validate those emotions and provide children a secure environment in which to share their feelings. But regardless of what the gentle parenting influencers claim, I do not think you can truly provide a safe space for your child if you are filming their instances of vulnerability and invading their privacy and self-respect in the act. If I’m honest, I do not believe these people have a lot to instruct any of us about child-rearing.

An Ending Thought

There are some who will see that as radical, who would balk at the fact that in some ways I’d rather put a dairy product on my son's forehead for a giggle than take advantage of his anguish as a teachable moment for views. But to them I would state this: if “each conduct is communication”, what, specifically, are these caregivers aiming to express?

About the author

Nathaniel Roberts

A passionate writer and urban explorer sharing insights on city living and cultural trends in the Middle East.

Urban Vibes

Type to search articles.